Friday, December 21, 2012

Bengals v Steelers - Take II




In the second half of the season, the Cincinnati Bengals have been the best team in the AFC North. Despite being 5-1 (compared to the 2-4 Steelers and the 3-3 Ravens) and in 2nd place in the AFC North the Bengals are still an afterthought in the national media and seen as the “Other Team” in the AFC North. For once, I agree with the national media. In order to be talked about with the “Big Boys,” you have to beat the “Big Boys.” Andy Dalton and these Bengals have yet to prove they can do that. Dalton is 17-7 against all teams not named the Steelers and Ravens and 0-6 against teams named the Steelers and Ravens. Until Dalton and this Bengals team beat the Steelers and Ravens, they will continue to be seen as the third team in the AFC North, regardless of their record. They get their chance these next two weeks, rarely have the Steelers and Ravens looked so vulnerable.



When the Steelers Run the Ball

It sounds like Rashard Mendenhall may be active this week. I’m not sure the Steelers fans should be happy about that or not. While none of the Steelers RBs have been very effective this year (the Steelers are 26th in the NFL in rushing), Mendenhall is the only Steelers RB who does not have a 100 yard game. In fact, the Steelers have only had 3 games this year with a 100 yard rusher, and haven’t had one since Redman went for 147 in week 9. However, 1 of their 3 100 yard games did come against these Bengals when Dwyer went for 122 in week 7. But, this is not the same Bengals defense. The last time these teams met, Crocker was just back and not starting, Burfict was new to the lineup, Rey Maualuga was still fat, and the defense as a whole was not playing well. Crocker is not starting at SS, Burfict is playing much better and faster, Maualuga is less fat, and the Bengals are now 9th against the run. In fact, the last 100 yard rusher the Bengals allowed was Dwyer. I believe the Steelers will have some success running delayed draws and reverses, but when they line up and run traditionally, I give the Bengals the edge.

Advantage: Bengals


When the Steelers Throw the Ball

Most teams run to set up the pass. The Steelers used to run to set up the run. These Steelers would much rather throw and they are very good at it. The Steelers are 10th in passing, despite missing Roethlisberger for 3 games and Antonio Brown for multiple games. In fact, last week, when Roethlisberger complained about the play calling, he threw for 339 yards. The Steelers have a deep and versatile receiving corps. They can stretch the field with Mike Wallace, one of the (if not the) fastest WRs in the game. They can come underneath with Brown, an excellent slot receiver. Or, they can beat you down the middle with Heath Miller, likely the most complete and underrated TE in the league. The Bengals, despite having the 12th ranked passing defense, cannot cover the Steelers receivers. That ranking is a result of the league leading 43 sacks. When they get pressure on the QB, the secondary can hold their own. When they don’t, the secondary gets exposed. The Steelers are depleted on the O-line, so the Bengals should be able to get pressure on Roethlisberger, but the key will be whether or not they can actually get him down. Roethlisberger is the best and most dangerous QB in the league when it comes to extending plays. If he can escape the pressure and extend plays, he will expose what has been a disappointing Bengals secondary. While I like the Bengals D-line over the Steelers O-line, the Steelers receivers are far better than the Bengals secondary.

Advantage: Steelers


When the Bengals Run the Ball

When these teams met in week 7, the Bengals run offense was struggling and BJGE was looking like a real disappointing signing. Something changed in the run game the last 5 weeks. After going the first 9 games with no 100+ yard games, BJGE has gone over 100 4 of the last five. The Bengals running attack is now ranked 11th, but playing like a top 10 or maybe even top 5 running attack. They will need it against the Steelers. The Steelers have the 4th ranked run defense and haven’t given up a 100 yard rusher since week 10 against the Chiefs. However, in 2 of their last 3 games, they have given up 5.8+ ypc to RBs (Murray 5.8, Rice 6.5). The Bengals will need to run the ball and stick to running the ball, if for no other reason than to keep the Steelers from focusing on Green. If the Bengals can have success running the ball, they will force the Steelers to pull coverage from Green, or allow the run game to beat them. A few weeks ago, I would have given the Steelers run defense the edge, hands down. However, the recent edge would go to the Bengals. I believe whoever wins this matchup will win the game.

Advantage: Push


When the Bengals Throw the Ball

The Steelers have the #1 ranked passing defense, which is astounding given the injuries they have had on defense. This week will be no different. Ike Taylor, who over the years has shut down the Bengals top WRs (Chad Johnson, AJ Green) on multiple occasions, will be out again. Of course that won’t stop Dick LeBeau from trying to scheme a way to neutralize Green. Without Taylor, that will likely be harder to do, but LeBeau is one of the best defensive minds of all time (if not the best), so I don’t put it past LeBeau. The question will be, can the running game or another WR or TE step up and hurt the Steelers? When the Bengals have had success over the Steelers in the past, they have hurt them with the secondary receivers (Houshmanzadeh, Caldwell, etc). With Sanu out, the question will be whether Jones, Hawkins, or Gresham can fill that void. So far, they have been very inconsistent doing so. The Bengals are right in the middle when it comes to passing offense (17th) and that is solely because of Green. If another receiver steps up, this is a top 10 passing attack. For that to happen against the Steelers defense will be a steep task. The Bengals have more talent when it comes to this matchup between DBs and WRs, but the Steelers have LeBeau, therefore, the Steelers get the edge.

Advantage: Steelers


Coaching

I hate the Steelers. But I love Mike Tomlin. If I could take 1 coach in the NFL for my team, I would take Tomlin. And if I had to pick 1 coach in a must win game, Tomlin would be #2 (Belicheck). Marvin Lewis would not be high on my list. Tomlin is 5-0 in his last 5 games against the Bengals. His players respond to him and with their backs against the wall, I expect them to come out playing well. In playoff scenarios, Lewis’s teams generally come out flat, looking unprepared and making mistakes. Not a good thing in a big game.

Advantage: Steelers


Conclusion

The winner of this game will make the playoffs as the 6 seed. Sure, the Bengals can still make the playoffs if they lose this game, but they would need to beat Baltimore and hope the Browns could beat the Steelers in Pittsburgh. I don’t see the Browns beating Pittsburgh again. So, don’t be fooled, this is a playoff/play in game for both teams. On top of that, this is a ‘prove yourself’ game for Andy Dalton. Dalton is a good promising young QB. He is 17-13 as a starter. He is only 1 of 3 QBs to throw 20+ TDs in their first 2 seasons (Marino and Peyton Manning). But, he has yet to beat the Ravens or the Steelers (0-6).  In games against teams other than the Steelers, Andy Dalton’s completion percentage is 61% and he averages 233 ypg. Against the Steelers, his completion percentage is  49% and he averages just 136 ypg. For Dalton and this Bengals team to get taken seriously, Dalton has to beat the Steelers and Ravens. I’m not exactly sure why, but my gut says Dalton finally gets it done.

Prediction:

Bengals 24, Steelers 20

No comments:

Post a Comment